Compare JD Edwards EnterpriseOne и RightCapital

Benefits:

In my opinion it is the best ERP in the market. I have worked with this ERP for more than twelve years, as a key user. It is flexible and easy to c... Read more

In my opinion it is the best ERP in the market. I have worked with this ERP for more than twelve years, as a key user. It is flexible and easy to customize and has a good support. For Manufactirung module, I think it is the best.

Drawbacks:

As it is easy to customize, when you need to update or upgrade the ERP, you have to spend more time testing.

Summary:

Unfortunately, I did not work with JD Edwards anymore, but it was a excellent ERP.

Benefits:

Integration was exactly as expected. JDE has been integral to our success in managing the financials, inventory management, supply chain management... Read more

Integration was exactly as expected. JDE has been integral to our success in managing the financials, inventory management, supply chain management. It's also easy to integrate other pieces of specialized software.

Drawbacks:

JDE requires a good amount of IT help to make any updates or adjustments this leads to upgrades happening slower than we'd like.

Summary:

JDE has made most of our processes significantly easier and more accurate.

Benefits:

JD Edwards E1 is very easy to use and navigate. line item details on ledger balance provide in depth information when doing account analysis . Cust... Read more

JD Edwards E1 is very easy to use and navigate. line item details on ledger balance provide in depth information when doing account analysis . Custom reports are available to help provide reporting needs

Drawbacks:

Attaching journal entry support can be improved so that it will take the file and able to view them when reviewing and approving journal entries

Summary:

JD Edwards is a very good ERP that can handle custom reporting and batch jobs system postings to help accounting to be more effective and efficient.

Benefits:

The only positive remark I can make about JDE CMMS is that it will be going away at this location, Soon

Drawbacks:

NOT user-friendly: at other locations I have trained Production AND Maintenance personnel in the use of CMMS / work order entry very effectively. ... Read more

NOT user-friendly: at other locations I have trained Production AND Maintenance personnel in the use of CMMS / work order entry very effectively. From the most savvy computer users to old guy who didn't even know what a mouse was for. JDE: like pulling teeth to get them to use the system at all because it is so difficult to learn and counter-intuitive to most users. Not efficient: First red flag I found in JDE was that it took more than 20 clicks / selections (at best - assuming ALL default selections could be accepted) to simply PRINT 1 Work Order. While working thru that process, it was necessary to indicate, at least twice, (this is a computer folks, why would you be required to repeat the object to be printed. (First step- select the W/O, then about step 8 or 10 it had to be selected again.) This was eventually corrected to allow a SINGLE W/O to be printed in 2 clicks, but multiple selections still require these steps. Not intuitive: there are (or were) places in JDE where selecting a RED X is/was required to SAVE steps accomplished in a process. This may have been changed to a green check or a disk in recent updates, but it still begs the question. ?WHY would ANY software make such a selection necessary? EVER.? Did I mention,... NOT Efficient: using other (very effective) software, the old guy (as well as most anyone else) could enter the critical data for a Work order in under 30 seconds after maybe a couple weeks of use. at this point, (9 years, 3 updates later) even I, the most experienced user on the CMMS System, cannot enter the data necessary to create a W/O in less than 3 minutes. and it does not just work orders that consume valuable time. most of the processes in JDE require so many repetitive actions, that it is sickening to watch some of the individuals perform their daily tasks from purchasing, inventory functions, etc. because so much time is wasted in the process. and to top it all off, from early on (to present day) when I was observing some of the folks who work with me perform those daily tasks, I noticed them exiting the process, then returning to the process, as though they were double checking the entries. when I inquired about this action / repeated steps, I was told that on occasion it was possible for you to "time-out" on your JDE access, and have absolutely Zero indication that had occurred. so all of these folks had gotten in the habit of exiting then re-entering to verify the information did indeed get saved to the system. I actually had a hard time believing this could happen, with no indication, until it happened to my co-worker who was working with me at the desk next to mine and I personally witnessed it. (less than 6 months ago)

Summary:

Benefits:

I've used five planning programs in 16 years. RightCapital has delivered the best value and customer service to date. The software is intuitive for... Read more

I've used five planning programs in 16 years. RightCapital has delivered the best value and customer service to date. The software is intuitive for most financial planners and doubles as an effective client portal.

Drawbacks:

No cons whatsoever. Everytime I think they could improve something, they come out with software updates that improve the experience/usability/forec... Read more

No cons whatsoever. Everytime I think they could improve something, they come out with software updates that improve the experience/usability/forecasting.

Summary:

Benefits:

The developers at RightCapital listen closely to the requests and pain points of their users and work continually to make improvements. After 2 yea... Read more

The developers at RightCapital listen closely to the requests and pain points of their users and work continually to make improvements. After 2 years using this software, I feel it has to be very close to the robustness of the most expensive planning software tools available on the market. The what if scenario planning is very powerful and fast.

Drawbacks:

While the tax reporting features are impressive, like showing 1040 form style reports, separate tax projection software is needed to run detailed y... Read more

While the tax reporting features are impressive, like showing 1040 form style reports, separate tax projection software is needed to run detailed year to year tax analysis. Further niche planning can be improved in areas like college, social security and long-term care planing. Account aggregration can also be improved.

Summary:

Overall I'm very satisfied with RightCapital. I can build and maintain high quality financial plans for my clients.